Are School Buses Safe Even Without Seat Belts?

Are you aware that there are special standards regarding school buses which need to be followed by every school?

 

You can be happy and relaxed about the fact that Indian government has taken all the measures to safeguard your “munchkin” at least on the trip to and back from the school. It is the AIS-063 standard that states the Rules & Regulations for Bus bodies for School Buses in India. Do you know what is covered in these standards? The physical features are—

 

  • “School Bus” or “On School Duty” on the school buses
  • First-Aid Box
  • Horizontal grills on windows
  • School Name and phone nos.
  • Doors should be lockable
  • Low Door Step
  • Speed governor- with a maximum speed of 40 Km/h
  • Special space for school bags
  • GPS and CCTV are compulsory
  • RFID tag for parents or guardian who come to pick up kids.
  • Two emergency exits
  • Flashing light or buzzer when bus door is open
  • High padded seats that reduce the impact of a crash

 touch eco- jcbl bus

 

All the school bus manufacturers comply with these features and aim to provide the best school buses. But do you think these are good enough for the children? We know that safety belts are compulsory in the cars, but still they don’t find any room in a school bus? Maybe because school buses are considered safe without seat belts or is it a neglected issue. We should identify any potential risk from all corners to safeguard our future generation.

 

Why School buses don’t have Seat belts?

 

why no seat belts

 

There are two conflicting sides to this question; we call these sides -schools of thought who have their own review on the installation of seat belts.

 

Recommended: Why School Buses Are Safer Means Of Transport For Kids?

 

The school of thought that advocates the necessity of seat belts represents its case as:

  • Buckling up at early ages in the school bus can go a long way of ensuring safety habit and kids can understand the importance of safety and security.

 

  • There is safety and security automatically attached to it and driver can focus better on driving.

 

  • This will ensure that the kids are seated and not running around in the moving bus.

 

  • This might also be a way to mitigate any litigation in case of any unfortunate mishap.

 

  • Parents, drivers and the school authorities will have some peace of mind.

 

No doubt, these are very crucial aspects for the safety of the kids but there is another school of thought that opposes this on the basis of safety, security also and cost-effectiveness. Their strong case highlights:

 

school bus by jcbl

 

  • School buses are as it is built and designed taking care of all safety precautions. So, safety belts will only increase the cost of the school bus without added any safety value.

 

  • On the contrary, it might be dangerous in an emergency situation, as it might delay in the evacuation process.

 

  • Height and weight of a School bus are designed in a manner that it can absorb any shock in case of an accident.

 

  • Compartmentalizationdesign holds the kids safely just like eggs in a carton, protecting them from shocks and abrasions.

 

  • Seat belts can be misused by the children as either a playful toy or as an instrument to hurt other kids.

 

  • All the kids don’t have a similar structure, weight, and height. Seat belts might fit some children perfectly while others might be just hanging in them. So, in an event of a crash, there is more probability that the students who have loose seat belts might hit the other students causing double injuries.

 

  • It has also been seen that lap belts have many a time incurred more injuries on necks due to a head-on collision.

 

Here, nobody can be stated right or wrong in his or her thinking because safety and security is their main concern. If we notice, then cons out rule the pros. On the face of it, we can easily suggest that the school buses are safe without the seat belts and there is no need to invest in seat belts in the school buses.

 

But, let me tell you of an incident that happened a few months back,

 

A School Bus Ferrying Kids to a Field Trip Crashes into a Dump Truck in New Jersey—

On 17th May 2018, a school bus ferrying kids to a field trip in New Jersey, USA collided with a dump truck. It rolled over and caused causalities. This crash resulted fatal for one child and one adult and injured 43 people. Analysts thought that the deaths could have been averted if occupants were buckled up!”

 

Must Read: Why Happy Bus Is The Safest School Bus?

 

This incident opens our eyes and shows us the dark side of not using the seat belts as an extra precaution in need of an emergency. But we also know that such incidents do not happen every day. With strict laws in India permitting speed limit of 40 Kmph for School buses and installation of speed governors, the safety quotient has increased.

 

 

Currently, in India seat belts in school buses are not compulsory due to the safety and security imposed through our stringent standards listed in AIS: 063. Safety has been endorsed to the core with the design, the speed, and types of seats, emergency exits, and many more. The main feature that stops the crash after effects is the “compartmentalization” which packs kids like eggs in the shells which minimize the impact of an injury.

 

For this purpose, the seats are cushioned along with a high back which helps to absorb the impact. These seats have strong anchorage and are spaced closely together to create compartments. This design with special compartments absorbs the impact scattering the impact throughout the body rather than restricting it to the neck. For this reason, the compartmentalization model is generally more favoured than the seat belt model. Safety seat belts in school buses will only add redundancy, along with extra cost.  So after calculated discussions in many committees in various states, seat belts have not been installed.

 

What are your thoughts on an installation of safety seat belts in school buses in India? 

Enjoyed the post? Please take some time to share it with your friends or leave a comment.

Have something to say?

Get Started Now & Experience The Difference

Call us

+91 172 3013095-96

Email Address

info@jcbl.com

Opening Hours

Mon-Fri 9am to 6pm
About Us

JCBL Limited, one of the renowned and committed coach builders in North India was formed in 1989, with a mission to design and manufacture high quality buses and load carriers that are innovative in style and engineering whilst maintaining standards of reliability. 

Contact us

  Office

        Plot No. 75, 1st Floor,

        Industrial Area, Phase-I

        Chandigarh - 160002

  +91 172 3013095-96

  +91 172 3013097

  info@jcbl.com

Copyright © 2017, JCBL Limited. All Rights Reserved.